Tell me about a time you had to decide what to build with very little direction, or with a stakeholder whose requirements were unclear.
Answer it out loud first, then compare. That's what makes it stick.
Situation: an operations director told me their reporting was broken, nothing more. Task: decide what to build in two weeks. Action: I shadowed three analysts for two days, found the real pain was reconciling two systems by hand, and proposed one testable milestone: an automated match for the top 20 percent of accounts. I wrote it down, got the director's sign-off, and built it. Result: reconciliation dropped from six hours to forty minutes a week, and we then scoped phase two with real data.
- Situation: what exactly was unclear and who owned it
- Task: the deadline and what you could decide alone
- Action: how you talked to users, narrowed to one testable milestone, got it agreed in writing
- Handle competing priorities among stakeholders
- Result with a number, then what you would do differently
Two public sources point at this theme. A candidate's Palantir recruiter screen asked about working directly with a stakeholder whose requirements were unclear, and the recruiter kept pressing on what the candidate did versus the team. Anthropic's postings ask FDEs to operate autonomously and navigate ambiguity in complex organisations, and prep guides turn that into a question about deciding what to build with little direction.
What interviewers score
- Agency: you did not wait to be told the priority.
- A method: you converted a vague complaint into something testable.
- Stakeholder handling: you kept people with competing goals aligned.
- Honesty: you can say what you got wrong.
A method you can name out loud
- Find the real user, not just the sponsor. Spend a day with the people doing the work; sponsors describe symptoms, users describe the actual steps.
- Write the problem in one sentence with a number: 'Analysts spend six hours a week reconciling two systems by hand.'
- Pick one milestone you can test in under two weeks. Prefer the narrowest slice with real data and a real user, such as the top 20 percent of accounts.
- Get it agreed in writing, including what is explicitly out of scope. A short page with the goal, the success measure and the first deliverable is enough.
- Demo early with real data (day 5, not day 14) and let reaction steer phase two.
Dealing with competing priorities
- Name the conflict openly: 'Finance wants audit trail, operations wants speed.'
- Offer a sequenced plan rather than a compromise that satisfies nobody.
- Escalate only the decision that is genuinely theirs, with your recommendation attached.
Common pitfalls
- Telling a well-specified project as if you had scoped it.
- Saying 'I asked my manager what to do'. That is the opposite of agency.
- Skipping the debrief. End with one thing you would change, for example 'I would have interviewed the downstream team earlier; we found a format issue in week three'.
Target about two minutes. Give one hard number in the result and one in the setup.
- Who disagreed with your first milestone, and how did you handle it?
- What did you leave out of scope and how did you tell people?
- How did you know you had found the real problem?
- What would you do differently if you ran it again?
- Palantir Forward Deployed Software Engineer (Commercial) Interview Experience (2026) - Aced (candidate, 2026-08-10) Recruiter screen asked about working with a stakeholder whose requirements were unclear and pressed on personal contribution.
- Anthropic Forward Deployed Engineer Interview (2026) (prep, 2026-10-25) Lists a deciding-what-to-build-with-little-direction question tied to the posting's ambiguity language.